Vintage Valuable

Serving Fort Myers, Cape Coral and all of SW Florida.

We buy Baseball Cards

The Coin & Jewelry Exchange is your one stop shop to sell or buy trading cards and collectibles.

We buy everything from one autographed card to entire warehouses full of inventory. We have been in the business for many years and will continue to bring value to our customers with fair prices and superior customer service. Our goal is to make our customers happy.

When you bring your items to us, you will meet face-to-face with someone who will help you make the right choice on your baseball cards. An honest and fair assessment will be made on what you offer.

What to Know About Selling Baseball Cards

Facts on How to Sell Baseball Cards

  • We buy hundreds of vintage baseball card collections each year. We buy and sells more baseball cards than anyone else in the area. The reason is very simple – we pay top CASH.
  • Most people who are trying to sell their vintage baseball cards are shocked to learn that most cards issued after 1980 have no real resale value.

You can count on The Coin & Jewelry Exchange to offer you our best price upfront when we bid on your sports card collection. We will do everything that we can to eliminate the hassles, confusion and stress of selling a vintage baseball card collection. We make our top Cash offer from the start so that everyone knows they are getting our best price.

Baseball cards have a different value, depending on who is on the card, the cards condition and when the card was issued.

Requirements to sell us Baseball cards:

  • Must be in good condition (not heavily worn).
  • Clean (no dirt, stains or damage)
  • 100% Authentic

Sports Cards and Memorabilia

If you have any of the following baseball cards hiding in your garage, you can sell them for top dollar for your cards. Here are a few examples of what we are looking to buy:

  • 1952 Topps Baseball Cd High Numbers (311-407)
  • Pre-War Baseball Cards – especially T-Cards or R-Cards
  • Any Mickey Mantle, Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Honus Wagner or Ty Cobb Baseball Cards.
  • Complete Baseball Sets from 1909-1979.

We are interested in buying collections of all sizes and guarantee the best price for your cards. We also offer a free quotation of your collection. For large or expensive collections, we will come to view and acquire your collection.

Here are a few of the baseball memorabilia we have available to purchase in our store.

Turn your baseball cards into cash right now! Lock in your price today! Call us at 239-209-2051 to get a quote for your baseball cards you would like to sell.

We Buy Vintage Comics

At The Coin & Jewelry Exchange, we treat you fairly, and with respect, at all times. We know that the decision to sell old comic books can sometimes be a tough one to make, due to a cash crunch, and that your books may have sentimental value. Turn your vintage comic books into CASH. We’re buying vintage comics, CGC graded comics and entire comic book collections.

Most big websites want your quality comic books on consignment or for their auctions. We will buy them auction fees, no risk that the buyer won’t pay or that the company that has your books will go out of business. Just a fair offer and immediate payment.

Why Choose Us?

  • Cash paid for your old comic books!
  • Fast unbeatable offers!
  • No auction fees!
  • No waiting!
  • Immediate cash in your pocket!
  • Our customer service is second to none. This is not all about money for us — we LOVE old comics!


What makes comic books valuable?

The value of a given comic book is determined by multiple factors, though there are some general guidelines that can help identify whether a comic is valuable or not. Comic books range in value from a few cents to millions of dollars, The most valuable comic books are the earliest superhero appearances. The vast majority of comic books, especially more modern editions, are worth cover price or less.

Though the first appearances of superheroes are generally regarded as the most valuable comic books, there are “holy grail” comics from each period of publishing history, like:

  • Action Comics #1 and Detective Comics #27 from the Golden Age
  • Showcase #4 and Amazing Fantasy #15 from the Silver Age
  • Incredible Hulk #181 and Marvel Spotlight #5 from the Bronze Age
  • Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #1 from the Copper Age
  • Walking Dead #1 from the Modern Age

Get the best price for all of your used comics! People all over the United States are looking to buy comics like The Dark Knight, All Star Superman, Batman: Year One, Crisis on Infinite Earths, X-Men, Superman, Fantastic Four, and of course Suicide Squad!

Don’t let your old comic books lay around your house collecting dust, use our price comparison site to get the most money for your used comics from our over 20 vendors.

Whether your used comics are Star Wars, Batman, Spiderman, Deadpool, Star Wars, Daredevil, or Suicide Squad comics, we make sure you always get the best offer for your old comics!

DC Comics Suicide Squad comic books are in demand right now, make sure you get the most money for your Suicide Squad comic books and all other Marvel, DC, Vertigo, and IDW comic books.

Vintage Items We Buy and Sell

  • Vintage Comics
  • Vintage Watches
  • Vintage Toys
  • Vintage Non Sports Cards & Collections
  • Vintage Video Games

New to Gold Selling/Buying?


Let's Chat

Schedule a free IN-HOME consultation today!